My Little South Park: Cheesy Poofs are Magic

Kyle- Element of Magic
Butters- Element of Laughter
Cartman- Element of Generosity (for an ironic effect)
Kenny- Element of Loyalty (since he always 'comes back')
Tweek- Element of Kindness
Stan- Element of Honesty
Ike- Spike

Bases by Butters: [link] Kyle: [link] Kenny: [link] Cartman: [link] Stan: [link] Tweek: [link]

(Sp)Ike is just a recolored picture of Spike.